Jump to content

Supreme Court Delays and Selective Justice; Efforts To Improve The Judicial System

Recommended Posts

  • Moderators

Supreme Court delays and selective justice


Posted 17/04/2019

there is no justification for the magistrates of Panama's   Supreme Court of Justice (CSJ) to continue dragging their feet in the processing of complaints against deputies of the National Assembly according to legal analysists and civil society.

After the publication by  La Prensa about outstanding charges against PRD deputy  Alfredo Fello Perez and his links to organized crime, and the delay of the judges in resolving processes is questioned.

One of the complaints against the PRD deputy gathering dust in the CSJ  is for alleged illegal trafficking of cocobolo wood. It has its origin in a police report of September 2012, before Perez held an Assembly seat.

Seven years have passed and there is still no definition of this process by the plenary of the CSJ says La Prensa.

Civilsectors warn that the is situation generated by the CSJ has affected the institutionality in the administration of justice.

Freddy Pitti, of the Together We Decide Movement, said pointed out that there is no justification for the CSJ not resolving an accumulation of complaints that have been filed against deputies.

He stressed that it has caused the population to lose confidence in public entities, mainly in the administration of justice and demonstrates the need to introduce profound changes in the political system through constitutional reforms.

Lawyer Ernesto Cedeño said that there seems to be a degree of selectivity in the administration of justice, evidenced by the speed with which some cases of deputies are filed, versus others that remain open. "The Court does not have the effervescence of complying with the administration of justice in  processes that  against deputies"

He shares Pitti's view that constitutional reform is required, in which a new mechanism is established to investigate and judge the lawmakers.

Carlos Lee, of the Citizens Alliance for Justice, the Panama branch of Transparency  International said that the apparent selectivity in the treatment of judicial cases faced by deputies is a constant in high-profile cases.

 Roberto Troncoso, former president of the Panamanian Committee for Human Rights, said that the handling of denouncements of the deputies in the CSJ has become a  "tug-of-war," when there is a tense situation between both organs of the State.

He dsod stressed there is a perception in the community of the existence of a kind of non-aggression pact between the Assembly and the CSJ  which has led to a lack of credibility in the judicial processes.

Electotal Shield 
Troncoso said that another factor affecting investigations of deputies is the electoral penal jurisdiction, which applies gives them a  legal shield.

The former vice president of the National Bar Association Juan Carlos Araúz believes that the legislation of the special processes that follows the deputies is, deliberately designed for impunity.

He said that the CSJ has exceeded its capacity to investigate a large number of complaints against deputies, which undoubtedly causes many to be prescribed.



Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 2 years later...
  • Moderators

Commission to Name Supreme Court Judges Installed


Posted 03/06/2021

The Special Evaluation Commission of the State Pact for Justice - which will evaluate candidates for magistrates of the Supreme Court of Justice (CSJ) was installed on Thursday, June 3.

The Executive summoned commission will  analyze the profile of the candidates to replace Hernán De León and Luis Ramón Fábrega, whose terms expire on December 31

Representatives of the 12 sectors that are part of that group attended the first, meeting held at the headquarters of the Office of the Attorney General.

Juan Carlos Araúz, president of the National Bar Association and spokesman for the commission, reported that the presentation of the resumes of the applicants begins on Friday, June 4. Those interested should take their papers to the Research and Training Center of the Public Prosecutor's Office in Llanos de Curundú, from 8:00 a.m. to 5:00 p.m.

Araúz that the criteria to be taken into account revolves around experience, profiles, critical vision of the state of justice, and the contributions that can be made.



Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Moderator_02 changed the title to Supreme Court Delays and Selective Justice; Efforts To Improve The Judicial System
  • Moderators

Moderator comment: Methinks the title of this news article should read “Weak justice institutions”.


Week justice institutions



The Institutional Quality Index 2021 of the Liberal Network of Latin America prepared by Martín Krause, professor of Economics at the University of Buenos Aires, reveals that Panama appears to be competitive in the field of market institutions, driven by the use of the dollar, economic openness, the banking center, etc. Taking into account only these factors, Panama ranks fifth on the continent, behind the United States, Canada, Chile, and Peru. But on the political level, its regional position falls to position 19. This poor result is the product of the weakness of our justice institutions, the rampant perception of corruption, and the lack of commitment of our leaders to be accountable. This places the country in positions of shame. In the global index, Panama lost a notch and will surely continue to worsen, it is clear that there is no will to improve its battered image; correct directions, fight corruption, and give an account of its management. If the country were to dispense with these burdens, we would surely be taking firm steps to become a developed country, but we are far from it and, as things are going, we will continue to move further and further away. - LA PRENSA. Jun. 7



Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.


  • Create New...